Intro
In the previous post, we looked at a pivotal moment in ancient Israel’s transition from being a stateless society to being a state-run society. Specifically, we looked at their establishment of a ruler over themselves, as described in 1 Samuel 8. A few key takeaways are:
- Samuel, as Yahweh’s spokesman, strongly objected to their appointment of a ruler.
- The features Samuel objected to are not specific to kingship (hereditary monarchy); they are common to all types of state power.
- The Hebrew word usually translated “king” actually means something closer to “ruler,” which certainly includes kings, but also other types of rulers.
In this post, we’ll take a closer look at pre-state Israel, focusing on establishing the fact that Israel really did exist as a stateless society before establishing a ruler, and also that they had this stateless political organization consciously and deliberately.
Israel — A Stateless Society
The Merneptah Stele
About 200 years before Saul became king, Pharaoh Merneptah (ruled 1213-1203 BCE) had a monument erected that provides the first established reference to Israel in the historical record. The inscription not only lets us know that Israel existed at the time, but it tells us something of its character.
The Merneptah Stele (1208 BCE)1This image is taken from Six Temples at Thebes by W. M. Flinders Petrie (1897) and is in the public domain.↓
Near the end of the inscription, we read the following:
Seized is the Kanaan with every evil,
Led away is Askelon,
Taken is Gezer,
Yenoam is brought to nought,
The people of Israel is laid waste,—their crops are not,
Khor (Palestine) has become as a widow for Egypt…
– Translation by Petrie in Six Temples at Thebes
Perhaps most obvious is the fact that this locates Israel in the land of Canaan (Kanaan). Canaan is overtly specified, and three Canaanite cities are mentioned by name: Askelon, Gezer, and Yenoam. Beyond this, there are some important things we can know based on certain features of the Egyptian hieroglyphic writing system. Hieroglyphics used symbols known as determinatives, which attached to the end of a word and indicated something about its meaning. For example, the words Askelon, Gezer, and Yenoam each have a determinative indicating that these terms refer to foreign (non-Egyptian) states.2More specifically, the determinative for these three cities consists of 2 signs: 1) a throwing stick (indicating foreignness) and 2) three hills (indicating a land, territory, city, etc.). In this case, it refers to city-states, which includes not only the city proper, but also the nearby surrounding region over which the city has control.↓ The word Israel, on the other hand, has a determiner for foreign peoples.3This determinative is also comprised of several signs: 1) a throwing stick, 2) a seated man, 3) a seated woman, and 4) three strokes — Z2 (indicating plural). Together, these indicate that the word Israel refers to a foreign group of people composed of males and females. Given the plural, perhaps it should be understood as “Israelite peoples,” which conceptualizes them as less unified than the term “the people of Israel” might suggest.↓ The reference to “their crops” indicates that they were a largely agricultural society.4The term translated by Petrie as “crops” may be more closely approximated by the English word “seed,” and some take it as a reference to Israel’s posterity. For a detailed argument in favor of understanding this term as a reference to agricultural seed, see Hasel, M. G. Israel in the Merneptah Stele*, Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, Number 296, Nov. 1994.↓
Altogether, the picture we get of ancient Israel from the Merneptah Stele is of a group of associated peoples living in Canaan who were a non-state entity that sustained itself mainly through agriculture.
Archaeology
The above is supported, and filled out, by the archaeology of early Israel, specifically in the period known as Iron Age 1 (1220-1000 BCE). Archaeology is one of those topics that is best understood with visuals and best explained by experts, so I’ve embedded here a couple of videos from a course by Andrea Berlin. I recommend watching the full course, available here: Archaeology of Israel (CNES 3172). To start, though, here are the two most relevant videos. I’ll highlight the most important aspects for our purposes below the videos.
There’s obviously a lot covered in those two videos, but note especially the plain evidence that Israel in this period was a decentralized society consisting of a network of small agricultural settlements. Its social-political organization was stateless and egalitarian, having no evident economic disparities. As for violence (an essential feature of statehood),5See 1 Samuel 8 and the State and Jesus’ Teaching on Nondomination: The Basics.↓ the settlements were established non-violently, as was inevitable since they were fresh settlements. Furthermore, they were non-militaristic, unfortified, unwalled hamlets. There is no evidence of weapons.
For a more detailed treatment of the archaeology of early Israel, I recommend William Dever’s Beyond the Texts: An Archaeological Portrait of Ancient Israel and Judah, particularly pages 119-257.6Beyond this, it’s also worth being aware of the following Wikipedia Articles, especially since they’ll likely be updated as more discoveries are made:
Israelite highland settlement
Ancient Israel and Judah > Iron Age 1 (13th-11th centuries BCE)↓ Something very important that Dever highlights is that early Israel was not just socially and politically separate from state entities; they were consciously and deliberately so. Dever points to a large amount of evidence that early Israelites were, on the whole, composed of people already living in Canaan during the transition from the Bronze Age to the Iron Age (around 1200 BCE). They had been under the thumb of the Canaanite city-states (which were themselves under the thumb of the Egyptian state) and likely included some city-dwellers and farmers of the lands connected with the cities. Here are some examples of the sorts of evidence leading to this conclusion: early Israelite pottery clearly continued the tradition of earlier Canaanite pottery; the Israelites also had the knowledge and technical ability to create waterproof cisterns carved into bedrock and then plastered; they terraced hills, built grain silos, made their own agricultural implements via metalworking, and constructed practical homes. This shows that the Israelites inherited the knowledge and the technologies present in the Bronze Age Canaanite states, but they now used them to enable their simpler country life.7There are other models proposed by various scholars for the origins of Israel. For example, Israel Finkelstein has put forward the idea that a large portion of early Israelites were newly settled pastoral nomads. To my mind, the evidence and argument presented by Dever shows that this can’t be the case for the majority of Israelites. The technologies and skills of early Israelites aren’t those of pastoral nomads, but of already-experienced farmers.↓ All this to say, the earliest Israelites weren’t stateless by default; they had lived under state power, but then withdrew from the state. This happened sometime before the Merneptah Stele (1208 BCE), and they remained stateless for about 200 years. They could have formed a state during that time, but chose not to. Here’s Dever on this point:
It is clear from the foregoing discussion that the Iron I villages presented here do not form anything like city-states, much less states. It is not, as some suppose, that the village complex here is too small. In cross-cultural analyses of what are called “state-formation processes,” it has been shown that polities as small as 25,000 or so can legitimately be regarded as true states, such as the Maya lowland states. By comparison, the total population of the Iron I villages discussed here has been estimated at 40,000-50,000 by the eleventh century—easily large enough to have formed before long the “early inchoate state” of cultural anthropologists.
It would appear that there is either a reluctance to enter into larger-scale political organization or simply no need for it.
– Beyond the Texts, p. 173
Dever then goes on to argue that the proto-Israelites deliberately withdrew from the state-run areas in Canaan, moving to the highlands where they could establish new settlements.
Indeed, in what will be described below as a deliberate withdrawal to colonize the highland frontier, our villages had literally gone out of their way to avoid all external authority. As Sahlins put it, “a society without a Sovereign” (see above.)
– Beyond the Texts, p. 179 (parenthetical note in original)
It is time to take up the notion of withdrawal again, but now with much more new supporting archaeological evidence and with different ideas about its motives. It was not only flight from intolerable conditions, or a supposed revolutionary Yahwistic fervor, that propelled people toward the frontier; it was more a quest for a new society and a new lifestyle. People wanted to start over—and in the end, that was revolutionary.
– Beyond the Texts, p. 224 (italics in original)
Again, the main point here is that the earliest Israelites deliberately withdrew from state-run society to found a stateless society, which lasted about 200 years. During those 200 years, they knew about other states, and they could have formed a state of their own if they wanted to, but they chose not to. The inevitable conclusion is that early Israel was not only a stateless society, but they were consciously and deliberately so.
Texts
In addition to the above evidence, there are also texts that present early Israelites as a self-consciously stateless society. In the last post, we actually already saw a little of this. But let’s look again at the most relevant parts.
1 Samuel 8
The Israelites said to Samuel,
Now, set for us a ruler to adjudicate us like all the nations.
– 1 Samuel 8:5 (Reflective English Translation)8This is one of my own translations.↓
Then, even after Samuel delivered to them Yahweh’s warning against setting up a ruler, we are told,
But the people refused to hearken at the voice of Shimūʾíl,9This reflects a more historically accurate pronunciation of Samuel’s name. There are problems with the treatment of names in most modern translations, such as rendering the Greek Ιακωβ as “James” when referring to Jesus’ brother or to either of his disciples who had that name, but as “Jacob” when referring to the ancient patriarch. Rendering this name differently even though the Greek is the same creates a false distinction between “Old Testament” and “New Testament” people, or worse, between “Jews” and “Christians.” This is but one example among many. The method I use is straightforward and avoids such inconsistencies — I opt to transliterate all proper nouns according to how they would have been pronounced at the time and in the language the text was written in.↓ and they said, “No! but a ruler must do his thing over us, so we too can do our thing like all the nations, and our ruler can adjudicate us, and proceed before our faces, and fight our wars.”
1 Samuel 8:19-20 (Reflective English Translation)
The fact that they wanted to become like all the nations indicates that they knew they were not like the nations. We’ll now look at a couple of bits of Archaic Hebrew poetry that also bear evidence of the same conclusion.
An Oracle of Balaam
The poems of Balaam in Numbers 23-24 are recognized by specialists in Ancient Hebrew as being written in a stage of Hebrew known as “Archaic Hebrew” or “Archaic Biblical Hebrew.”10See Remnants of Archaic Hebrew Poetry Embedded in the Torah by Tania Notarius. (She references plenty of other scholarly works on Archaic Hebrew in the footnotes.)↓ Scholars debate exactly when they were composed,11 William F. Albright dated the written form of the poems to around the 10th century BCE and the original oral composition to the 12th century BCE. See The Oracles of Balaam, Journal of Biblical Literature, Vol. 63, Iss. 3, pp. 207-233.
Baruch Levine dates the oracles to the first half of the 9th century BCE. See Numbers 21-36: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (AYB 4A), p. 232.
Philip Budd dates them to the 10th or early 9th century BCE. See Numbers, World Biblical Commentary, Volume 5, p. 263.
Tania Notarius dates the written form to early monarchy, but says they “could have had a long history of oral transmission stretching back into the pre-classical/pre-monarchic period.” See Remnants of Archaic Hebrew Poetry Embedded in the Torah.↓ but they are among the earliest texts in the Hebrew Bible, and the poem we’ll quote from (Numbers 23:7-10) plainly describes Israel in its pre-state phase. Here’s the relevant section:
From ʾArám, Baláq ruler of Mōʾáb leads me,
— from the mountains of the east.
“Come, curse Yiʿqúb for me,
— and come, denounce Yiśraʾíl.”
How can I damn when ʾIl hasn’t damned?
— And how can I denounce when Yahwéi hasn’t denounced?
Yet from the head of rocks I see them,
— and from hills I behold them.
Here is a people who dwells apart,
— and they don’t construe themselves among the nations.
– Numbers 23:7-9 (Reflective English Translation)12The names may at first seem unfamiliar due to being written in a way to reflect their ancient pronunciation. Yet, for the most part, they are pretty similar to the common names. For example, ʾArám = Aram, and Mōʾáb = Moab. Yiʿqúb is a bit further from what you’re used to: Jacob. The transliteration Yiʿqúb is based on the fact that this name is a nominalized verb, specifically a 3ms yiqtol form in Qal, which would have had the form yiqtul in earlier stages of Hebrew. Eventually, the “i” changed to “a” due to the guttural עׁ, and the “u” changed to “o.” If you have evidence that either or both of these changes took place already in Archaic Hebrew, please let me know; I’ll be happy to update this. Also, ʾIl is the name of the High God known to Canaanites long before the name Yahweh was known. It is the divine name embedded in the name “Israel” — Yiśraʾíl.↓
Very plainly, this portrays Israel as self-consciously distinct from the nations — not regarding themselves as among the nations.
As always, there’s more to say, but that’ll have to wait for future posts. 🙂
Footnotes
- 1This image is taken from Six Temples at Thebes by W. M. Flinders Petrie (1897) and is in the public domain. ↩︎
- 2More specifically, the determinative for these three cities consists of 2 signs: 1) a throwing stick (indicating foreignness) and 2) three hills (indicating a land, territory, city, etc.). In this case, it refers to city-states, which includes not only the city proper, but also the nearby surrounding region over which the city has control. ↩︎
- 3This determinative is also comprised of several signs: 1) a throwing stick, 2) a seated man, 3) a seated woman, and 4) three strokes — Z2 (indicating plural). Together, these indicate that the word Israel refers to a foreign group of people composed of males and females. Given the plural, perhaps it should be understood as “Israelite peoples,” which conceptualizes them as less unified than the term “the people of Israel” might suggest. ↩︎
- 4The term translated by Petrie as “crops” may be more closely approximated by the English word “seed,” and some take it as a reference to Israel’s posterity. For a detailed argument in favor of understanding this term as a reference to agricultural seed, see Hasel, M. G. Israel in the Merneptah Stele*, Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, Number 296, Nov. 1994. ↩︎
- 5
- 6Beyond this, it’s also worth being aware of the following Wikipedia Articles, especially since they’ll likely be updated as more discoveries are made:
Israelite highland settlement
Ancient Israel and Judah > Iron Age 1 (13th-11th centuries BCE) ↩︎ - 7There are other models proposed by various scholars for the origins of Israel. For example, Israel Finkelstein has put forward the idea that a large portion of early Israelites were newly settled pastoral nomads. To my mind, the evidence and argument presented by Dever shows that this can’t be the case for the majority of Israelites. The technologies and skills of early Israelites aren’t those of pastoral nomads, but of already-experienced farmers. ↩︎
- 8This is one of my own translations. ↩︎
- 9This reflects a more historically accurate pronunciation of Samuel’s name. There are problems with the treatment of names in most modern translations, such as rendering the Greek Ιακωβ as “James” when referring to Jesus’ brother or to either of his disciples who had that name, but as “Jacob” when referring to the ancient patriarch. Rendering this name differently even though the Greek is the same creates a false distinction between “Old Testament” and “New Testament” people, or worse, between “Jews” and “Christians.” This is but one example among many. The method I use is straightforward and avoids such inconsistencies — I opt to transliterate all proper nouns according to how they would have been pronounced at the time and in the language the text was written in. ↩︎
- 10See Remnants of Archaic Hebrew Poetry Embedded in the Torah by Tania Notarius. (She references plenty of other scholarly works on Archaic Hebrew in the footnotes.) ↩︎
- 11William F. Albright dated the written form of the poems to around the 10th century BCE and the original oral composition to the 12th century BCE. See The Oracles of Balaam, Journal of Biblical Literature, Vol. 63, Iss. 3, pp. 207-233.
Baruch Levine dates the oracles to the first half of the 9th century BCE. See Numbers 21-36: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (AYB 4A), p. 232.
Philip Budd dates them to the 10th or early 9th century BCE. See Numbers, World Biblical Commentary, Volume 5, p. 263.
Tania Notarius dates the written form to early monarchy, but says they “could have had a long history of oral transmission stretching back into the pre-classical/pre-monarchic period.” See Remnants of Archaic Hebrew Poetry Embedded in the Torah. ↩︎ - 12The names may at first seem unfamiliar due to being written in a way to reflect their ancient pronunciation. Yet, for the most part, they are pretty similar to the common names. For example, ʾArám = Aram, and Mōʾáb = Moab. Yiʿqúb is a bit further from what you’re used to: Jacob. The transliteration Yiʿqúb is based on the fact that this name is a nominalized verb, specifically a 3ms yiqtol form in Qal, which would have had the form yiqtul in earlier stages of Hebrew. Eventually, the “i” changed to “a” due to the guttural עׁ, and the “u” changed to “o.” If you have evidence that either or both of these changes took place already in Archaic Hebrew, please let me know; I’ll be happy to update this. Also, ʾIl is the name of the High God known to Canaanites long before the name Yahweh was known. It is the divine name embedded in the name “Israel” — Yiśraʾíl. ↩︎